Skip to content
Workers sorting recyclable packaging into yellow bags in a warehouse.

The guarantee-return system five months after implementation. Part 2

RetuRo answers questions about people's grievances. Retailers who don't give money and packaging that must be intact.

8 May 2024 Teodora Ghenciu
The guarantee-return system five months after implementation. Part 2

Recyclable Packaging Sorting

share

Five million packages a day, as the environment minister claims are collected in those supermarket machines, is an impressive figure, no matter how critical you might want to be of the Deposit-Return System. These are PET bottles, aluminum cans, and glass bottles that we no longer see in fields, along riverbanks, or in lakes, but are neatly and civilly gathered in a sorting center and from there sent for recycling.

Of course, this figure of five million must be compared to the enormous amount of beverage packaging put on the market, which is seven billion packages annually. So, if the collection rate remains at five million packages a day, it would indeed be too slow a pace, and we would collect too little. Too little compared to the seven billion.

But the pace is increasing month by month. For example, in the first three months of 2024, three complete months - January, February, March - approximately 100 million packages were collected. And in a month and a half, April plus half of May, 250 million packages were collected. So, a 150% increase in such a short period is encouraging, I would say.

This is where our role comes in. As citizens. Because we can directly contribute to increasing the recycling rate of waste in Romanian cities, which you know is shamefully low, averaging somewhere around 12-13%.

Sure, we could have contributed until now, just by separating our waste. But with data not being so transparent and reported monthly, the feeling of contribution wasn't as tangible. And no, this doesn't mean I'm putting pressure on the citizen, the poor citizen who often seems to have to take on all the responsibility of the state or companies.

It's evident that the state, companies, the system, must do their part. It's evident that we need functional infrastructure to increase the separate collection rate and meet our recycling targets. It can't be done otherwise. But even if we had the infrastructure and people didn't use it, it still wouldn't be good.

That's why I don't think I'm exaggerating when I say that it seems to me that for the first time, citizens can feel empowered, through individual, visible, measured contribution, to a common, national goal.

"We want to, but the system doesn't work!", those who have encountered various problems when trying to return packages will probably say. From machines that were blocked, retailers who refused to accept bottles, to stores that refuse to give money or crush PET bottles, claiming they don't have space. Let's take them one by one!

I've already written about the first two problems in a previous article, which I invite you to read here. Now we focus on the next two.

Retailers who refuse to offer money

I've heard there are situations where people make the effort to take bottles with the “Deposit Package” logo back to the store, but instead of receiving the equivalent in cash, 50 bani for each package, they receive a shopping voucher.

It's true that hypermarket machines can only issue vouchers, they can't dispense cash, as they are not ATMs. But with that voucher, the person can go to the checkout and ask for cash if they wish. It's their choice. The retailer receiving the packages shouldn't force them to shop there.

Moreover, the consumer can request that the money be transferred directly to their account if they don't want cash. However, in this case, they must bear the bank fees.

I asked RetuRO, the SGR administrator, what people who experience this, who are denied the right to receive cash or card payments, can do.

Anca Marinescu, Corporate Affairs and Communication Manager RetuRO:

"First of all, they should point out that they are in a situation where the law is not being respected and that it is very important for everyone to respect the law as long as we live here and claim we want a better life.

But I think it's a moment where, truly, some retailers don't understand.

We can contact the retailer and tell them, look, it has been reported that vouchers are not accepted at your store. You know you're against the law, you know it's not right. At least let's try to explain it to them again. We are doing a lot of education with retailers right now. I have colleagues who go out in the field and talk to each of them. Over 20,000 retailers have been visited so far. And the universe we are targeting is 50,000 retailers."

The issue of intact packages

In the complaints department, I've noticed that some people are unhappy with the rule of not crushing packages. If it comforts you, in all 15 countries where a Deposit-Return System has been implemented, collection is done the same way. Packages must be intact, undeformed, so the barcode can be read. For a very simple reason, explains RetuRO, to avoid fraud.

"There is a risk that if you crush them, when they reach our centers, they won't be recognized. Because even in our RetuRO centers, the equipment that does the counting is also automated, like the RVMs.

They are the same equipment, set in the same way. They have the same settings behind them. So if your package is crushed, the risk is that the barcode won't be visible, it won't be recognized, and you won't receive the money for that package, the deposit, and the management fee.

It's ultimately in the retailer's interest," says Anca Marinescu.

Therefore, there are no exceptions. Whether you're a small retailer and say you have too little space and nowhere to store PET bottles, cans, and beverage bottles, you are not allowed to crush them.

Why Romania is different

We are not more Catholic than the Pope when it comes to package collection, yet there are some peculiarities of Romania when we talk about the Deposit-Return System.

First of all, we are the second-largest country implementing such a system, after Germany. However, compared to the Germans, where collection is done by land, ours is done in an integrated manner, managed at the national level.

"RetuRO is a unique operator at the country level. We have a different geography. We are quite spread out compared to other countries that have implemented it, like Slovakia, Malta, Ireland. They are much smaller countries. We are talking about huge volumes of packaging compared to other countries. Seven billion packages we estimated annually, compared to two billion in Slovakia, for example, under a billion in Ireland, completely different volumes.

Then, what makes us unique is how we organize commerce. Because in most countries, we talk about modern trade, large chains of hypermarkets, supermarkets, in a proportion of about 80%. Which makes the system much easier to implement. In our case, the proportion is only 50%," Anca Marinescu, Corporate Affairs and Communication Manager RetuRO, tells us in the video interview.

This explains why over 90% of the collected packages come from machines, even though the law does not require us to collect them only this way. Collection can also be done manually, which would help small stores, especially in rural areas, where there is still reluctance, especially where sellers have no space and where SGR seems like an additional burden.

Who are the recycling champions

The recycling dance has so far been played more in cities, where, ironically, I don't know how many people still know how to dance to folk music.

Between January 1 and April 15, 2024, the recycling champions were, as expected, the residents of the capital and its surroundings, followed by large cities where there are also large stores.

Collected packages

Bucharest: 38 million Ilfov: 10 million Timis: 9 million Cluj: 8 million Constanța and Brașov: 7 million Prahova and Mureș: 6 million

There is still a long way to go. And yes, maybe Romania has many peculiarities, we are a fairly large country, we produce a lot of packaging, we have many neighborhood stores, but that doesn't mean we have to be different in terms of results. If everywhere it has been implemented, the system started to be effective from the second or third year of operation, when the collection rate approached, in many cases, 90%, I don't see why we should be any less.

All we need to do is manage to bring the dance back to the village. And to get those with small stores to collect as well.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Deposit-Return System?

The Deposit-Return System is a recycling initiative that encourages consumers to return beverage containers like PET bottles, aluminum cans, and glass bottles to designated machines in supermarkets for a refund. This system aims to reduce litter and increase recycling rates.

How many packages are collected daily under this system?

According to the environment minister, approximately five million packages are collected daily through the Deposit-Return System. This includes various types of beverage containers that are then sent for recycling.

What is the current recycling rate in Romania?

Romania's recycling rate is currently quite low, averaging around 12-13%. This highlights the need for improved waste management practices and increased public participation in recycling efforts.

How has the collection rate changed recently?

The collection rate has seen significant improvement, with around 100 million packages collected in the first three months of 2024 and an impressive 250 million packages collected in just a month and a half. This reflects a 150% increase in collection efficiency.

What role do citizens play in increasing recycling rates?

Citizens play a crucial role in increasing recycling rates by actively participating in the Deposit-Return System and properly separating their waste. Their involvement is essential for the success of recycling initiatives and improving overall waste management.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Be the first to learn about the latest sustainability news